Recapping the Chancellor search listening sessions

On Friday, November 13th, two faculty listening sessions were hosted by executive vice president and provost at UNL David Jackson and Zach Smith from the search firm WittKieffer who will assist the 31-member search committee with candidate recruitment and evaluation. Members of our chapter tuned in, attended, and spoke at the listening sessions, providing this information to keep Bugeater readers informed about what is already underway. We will continue to monitor the process, and seeking answers to our questions for what we want to see, and how we want the search to go for the University’s next leader.

The sessions began by briefly outlining the process for selecting our next chancellor. Smith and two others from the search firm will create a position description to be released in early January 2027 with some input from the faculty through the listening sessions and the portal for comments through an online survey linked on the Chancellor Search website. (A note that listening sessions were also held for staff and students. The online survey can be used by anyone, including alumni, administration, and community members.) The search firm will advertise the position in “strategic outlets” and also build a “target list of candidates” from other land grant and R1 institutions. They also invite the search committee and the campus community to participate with nominations. They will contact “hundreds of people.” 

After a closing date in mid-February, applications will be reviewed and candidates evaluated with a goal of selecting 3, possibly 4, candidates for confidential interviews with the search advisory committee. The committee’s charge is to identify approximately three highly qualified individuals for President Gold’s consideration. Once a priority candidate is selected by Dr. Gold, there will be a 30-day vetting period with the candidate on campus and across the state and opportunities to provide an assessment and input on the potential hire. The final selection of chancellor is made by Dr. Gold and the Regents.

Zach Smith from WittKieffer explained that they are a firm that focuses on university presidents, chancellors, etc. and some of their previous clients include University of Minnesota and Rutgers.

Faculty were invited to respond to four questions at the listening session that are also on the online survey. 

1. What do you think should be the top priorities for the next Chancellor of the University of Nebraska-Lincoln?

2.To effectively address these priorities and lead the University, what personal qualities and professional qualifications are most important to seek in the next Chancellor?

3. Are there specific points of pride about the University you think are most important to share with candidates?

4. What additional information would you like the search committee and search firm to know as the search gets underway?

Faculty Participation

Fewer than 20 faculty were present in the room for the listening session on city campus, and an unknown number were also participating on zoom (because of the way the meeting was set up). The comments were wide ranging but generally unified. Faculty who spoke were from several colleges including Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, Arts and Sciences, Business, Education and Human Sciences, and Fine and Performing Arts, some recent hires and others who have been at UNL for well over two decades. 

One faculty member noted the low in-person turn-out for the listening session as a sign of the level of disaffection and how little faculty think they have a voice here. An example is that the 31-member search committee was formed without a solicitation of nominations from faculty or consultation with the Faculty Senate. It was also noted by more than one professor that UNL has a very unusual administrative structure at the top among the chancellor, vice chancellors, and the president that makes this position especially challenging because the chancellor does not have control of the majority of resources for UNL. This is especially complex as UNL integrates with the Medical Center. We want to be certain that each campus retains its unique character and that our chancellor knows how to navigate up, down, and across.

Transparent Communication

Many of the faculty comments stressed the need for transparent communication with the faculty in general and certainly in major decision-making processes such as choosing vice chancellors. One member of the faculty asked how the search firm would assess candidates’ commitments to transparency, meaningful shared governance, faculty empowerment, and rebuilding institutional trust and morale. Jackson and Smith said they look for a candidate’s “positive past,” how they learn from mistakes, call references, full media checks, and how they communicate. 

Faculty members present were critical of closed searches for administration including the structure of the chancellor search. There are several concerns about this process because of its lack of transparency including that faculty will never know the size of the candidate pool. It appears that the search process is based on a maximum secrecy interpretation of the law, not a maximum transparency interpretation. This process does not bode well for trust necessary for a good working relationship.

Faculty members asked how the search firm will handle recruiting candidates for a campus that just held a no confidence vote of our last chancellor and asked if the search firm had read the text of the no confidence vote. (The firm had not.) Again, this vote was partially about the lack of transparent communication. The search firm did not address an online comment about a conflict of interest with the interim chancellor being a candidate. This could limit the search firm’s ability to recruit external candidates.

Losses of Faculty, Units, and Support Systems

One faculty member from a unit that was eliminated said that the administration is good at making public statements about plans that appear to be transparent and supportive of faculty and students, but that declaring it will happen does not mean that there is an understanding of how it will happen and with what resources. In response, the search firm representative said they do a “360 approach to reference scenes,” talking to colleagues, and people who have managed them and whom they have managed. They also contact Faculty Senate presidents to get at the pulse of the faculty.

Faculty members mentioned how many support systems on campus have been cut including tutoring centers, the Office of Diversity and Inclusion, the Gender and Sexuality Center, and other programs that support students on the margins. We all feel the loss of these and some question our own sense of belonging here. Retention is a critical issue for UNL, and these programs help to retain students, staff, and faculty. Belonging and inclusion must be high priorities for the next chancellor.

Several faculty members pointed out that the chancellor must believe that the university is not a business, but a public good and that in addition to transparency and communication, the chancellor must have integrity. There has been a lack of integrity in our campus and system leadership where they use words like “extraordinary” and “bold” while their actions have shown neither. Rather, faculty and units have been pitted against one another through faulty metrics used to decide cuts. These actions do not build morale or unity; they burn out and eventually break faculty. Integrity means telling the truth, saying what they really mean, and following through. Past “listening sessions” seem like exercises in futility to faculty who do not feel heard. We get AI-generated platitudes that substitute for authentic engagement. 

Another faculty member was quite clear in saying that we have lost many colleagues to cuts, but many more have left on their own accord because of the low morale and bad leadership at UNL. This colleague warned that if this process and incentives remain the same as most processes and incentives for hiring this type of position, we’re going to end up with a very similar profile to what we’ve had before, and that’s not what the university needs right now. We do not need a corporate operational manager. We need a visionary who works with the faculty on a shared mental model. Running the university foremost as a business, rather than a public good, is a losing game of cost control that destroys our own resources and capabilities that leave us unable to compete.

Several faculty members stressed the necessity of the chancellor to serve as an advocate for UNL both inside and outside with the legislature, governor. and the general public so that resources can be increased because there is no more left to cut.

Points of Pride

Many faculty members lauded the excellence of their colleagues, students, and staff but said that UNL today is not at all the same institution they were excited to join when hired. One faculty member said that if the candidate comes to campus and meets our faculty and students, they will want to come here, regardless of how tough the job may be. But they must understand that we are burned out and traumatized by last year’s unit and major eliminations. The next chancellor must rebuild trust with and among the faculty and staff.

It was pointed out that our last chancellor was unable to speak at all about the arts and humanities. There seems to be a large emphasis on agriculture from the search firm, but we need a chancellor who understands and supports every unit on our campus and who prioritizes academics over athletics. We have excellence in all fields across campus that can be seen in the annual Research Reports, and the search firm and committee are encouraged to become conversant on them.

Several faculty members stressed that our next chancellor must be a well-regarded scholar with a PhD and a teaching and research background that matches the level at which we’re expected to perform. We feel that the last chancellor did not fit this profile. We need a world-class scholar to lead us.

One faculty member stressed that the next chancellor not only be data-driven (as will likely be in the position description) but must also be data-literate and data facile. The chancellor must be able to interpret the data, not just rely on someone else’s summary of it.

Another faculty member’s online comment summarized the general spirit of the listening session: “Faculty members want the next chancellor to be visionary, transparent, approachable, decisive, and collaborative in their leadership. They must have demonstrated financial and academic management, experiencing respect for shared, management experience, respect for shared governance, and understanding of disciplinary differences, a commitment to developing academic talent, and the ability to advocate effectively for UNL within the Nebraska University system and beyond. We need more than a crisis manager. We need a leader who can rebuild confidence, recognize excellence beyond standardized metrics, empower academic units, and inspire a shared institutional purpose. The next Chancellor must understand that “academic excellence is an ecosystem and that that lasting success requires investment in people, programs, and opportunities, not simply greater efficiencies.”